I think we did too many bold votes on this pokemon. Bold votes are good for discussion, and they can alleviate multiple polls in some cases. That's good.
But, this project needs to be accessible to newcomers. I know some of you may not like it, but people need to be able to "drive-by" vote on this project. That's the way people get interested in the project.
If they vote, then they have incentive to track the results. If they track the results, they have incentive to track the discussion. If they track the discussion, they have incentive to post. If they post, they have incentive to get involved.
There are LOTS of lurkers on this project (and Smogon, in general). Many lurkers do not like to post. Smogon is an intimidating place, and posting can be a little scary. Click polls are a great low-risk way for people to "get their feet wet" on this project. I know we don't want a bunch of dumbass noob posts here. I'm fully aware of the whole "lurk moar" mentality. I agree with it. But, many aspects of this pokemon do not require expert analysis, forethought, and debate. Many times, all you need to do is, "Look at the options and pick your favorite". In that regard, the CAP project is almost unique it it's ability to appeal to a broad range users, from the newbs to the most seasoned competitive battlers.
Also, you can't track progress with bold votes. One of the great things about click polls, is that results are constantly visible. Yes, this can lead to bandwagon voting. But, it also encourages people to "check in" from time to time to see how the poll is progressing. With bold votes, you can't see the progress and the posts aren't exactly "thrilling" either. Almost all the bold vote posts, are just that -- bold votes. No enlightening discussion or anything -- just the options from the OP with some of them bolded. So people don't track the threads, and that curbs involvement.
Too many bold polls -- it's a total buzzkill on the project. It makes it harder to vote, it discourages people from checking in frequently, and it's less inviting to project newcomers.
The reason we started bold voting was to eliminate multiple polls on the same thing, and to encourage more discussion and less "drive-by" voting. I think those goals are commendable. But, on this project, we went too far with it.
Too many click polls are bad thing, but too many bold polls are a bad thing also. Next time, we need to make a concerted effort to strike a balance.